Mod 13: The Amulet #1: The Stonekeeper Review

What's It All About?

Emily and Navin must move with their mother to their deceased great-grandfather's house after their dad passes away. The house is strange and filled with secrets. When their mom is lured into the basement by an unknown creature they are the only ones who can save her. They end up stepping into a world filled with talking animals, and demons. Will they save their mom? What secrets will they find in this secret world?

What'd I Think?

I can definitely see why this is popular with the tween boy set. It is rich with fantasy and adventure on top of creepy demons. The illustrations are spot on. It wasn't my favorite graphic novel ever but it was a good read.

I give it 3 out of 5 stars!

What'd They Think?

School Library Journal

(January 01, 2008; 9780439846806)

Gr 4 Up-Hurrying to pick up her brother, Emily and her parents have a tragic accident, and her father dies. After this dark beginning, the story skips forward two years to when the remaining family members are forced to move to an ancestral house in a small town. Rumored to be haunted, it is unkempt and forbidding. The first night there, Emily's mother goes down to the basement to investigate a noise and doesn't return. The kids search for her and discover a doorway into another world, where their mother has been swallowed by a monster and is being taken away. An amulet that Emily found in the house tells her that together they can save her, but her brother isn't so sure that this voice can be trusted. Still, what other choice do they have in this strange place? Gorgeous illustrations with great color bring light to this gloomy tale. Filled with excitement, monsters, robots, and mysteries, this fantasy adventure will appeal to many readers, but it does have some truly nightmarish elements.-Dawn Rutherford, King County Library System, Bellevue, WA (c) Copyright 2010.

Publishers Weekly

(January 28, 2008; 9780439846813)

Almost too clever and poignant, Amulet is, on the surface, about navigating the murky waters of adolescence and, beneath that, an exploration of abandonment and survival. Emily and Navin are lost children, literally lost in a dark, new world and struggling to save their mother, who has been kidnapped by a drooling, tentacled beast. With stellar artwork, imaginative character design, moody color and consistent pacing, this first volume's weakness lies in its largely disjointed storytelling. There is the strong, young, heroine; cute, furry, sidekicks; scary monsters-all extraordinary components, but pieced together in a patchwork manner. There is little hope in his dark world as Kibuishi removes Emily and Navin's frame of safety. Their hopes rest in a magic amulet that seems to be working in the interest of the children-until it suddenly isn't. The most frightening element of Amulet is the sense of insecurity we feel for Emily, fighting her way through uncharted terrain with no guide and no support system. This first volume of Amulet isn't a disappointment, but it does feel like a warmup to the main event. If anything, it's a clear indication that Kibuishi has just begun skimming the surface of his own talent. (Jan.) (c) 

What Do I Do With It?

After reading this graphic novel and discussing the format students can create their own graphic novel showing how they think the series will continue. Once the novels are complete they can be compared/contrasted with the second book in the series.